Fantasy Hype Train vol. II: Hopping the Rails

Self-attribution bias theorizes that, if a single person experiences success, it was by their own doing, while setbacks or failures come about due to others or circumstances or anything BUT that given person's actions. It leads to people erroneously trusting in their own decisions and ideas without critical examination. SAB factors into player hype inflation just as much as any other aspect of one's life. Dropping a penny on a train rail in the hopes of appearing on the five-o-clock news surveying fresh wreckage is not only a possible sign of major psychoses, but also of naivete; even if one didn't know such a story had been debunked over a century ago as pure myth, the idea that a sliver of pliable ore could flick tons of metal into the air like a dandelion head should ring a skepticism bell somewhere. Excessive speed, be it via neglect or hubris or whatever, CAN induce a rail-hop. What I'm trying to get at through this contrived and woefully-thin allegory is that one's plans can launch off the rails through excessive hype for a given player, disregarding pitfalls due to situational blindness. This exercise looks at a pair of well-liked fantasy prospects through an objective and critical lens, so our excitement doesn't leave us like the opening scene in Unbreakable.

A wildly underrated movie, by M. Night Shyamalamadingdong, no less

C.J. Spiller

MFL ADP: 52, Fantasy Pros ranking: 62 (RB26)

Spiller's road has been a long one thus far. A former first-round pick of the Bills, he cobbled together only one productive season, but damn, was it a great one. Spiller's 2012 seems ethereal now, but its memory still tugs at our senses come draft time. His ceiling is sky-high, we rationalize, which isn't wrong at all. But potential alone cannot justify a player's price...so we look to his new surroundings. Spiller left Buffalo in the lurch this offseason and now fills Pierre Thomas/Travaris Cadet's old role in New Orleans. Combined, the duo saw 106 of the team's 154 RB targets last year, a number that could grow in the post-Jimmy Graham era. Pundits expect Spiller to be third on the team in overall targets, behind sophomore Brandin Cooks and senior citizen Marques Colston. Momentum is already building behind his market value as people sum his talent with the new offense. It's a volatile situation that promises to exacerbate gradually; one must keep the Spiller love in check and correct for his possible failings. As I've previously mentioned, Sean Payton has gradually retooled his offense into a more balanced attack than it once was, hoping to feature Mark Ingram as the primary weapon outside Drew Brees; this will likely lead to an effort to keep two tight ends on the field more often, which would mean Spiller will either split out wide or just come off the field. While Spiller's lack of other production in Buffalo resulted partly from the coaching staff having its collective head up its ass regarding Spiller's ability in space ("WHY ARE YOU RUNNING HIM BETWEEN THE TACKLES OVER AND OVER?"), it still carries weight. We've seen glimpses on the field since 2012, but nothing substantial enough to convince me that it wasn't an outlier season. Another bit to recall is Spiller's penchant for getting hurt. He's missed 8 games over the past two years and still fights off a lingering ankle issue. At his current ADP, Spiller is right at the intersection of worth and value: you're getting exactly what you pay for. I expect his price to bubble over into the third round as the offseason buzz grows louder and beat writers pump him up even more than they already have, which makes him too much of a possible liability outside of PPR leagues for my tastes.

Melvin Gordon

MFL ADP: 30, Fantasy Pros ranking: 29 (RB13)

Ho-lee shit. Rookie Derangement Syndrome once more attacks our young and burns our villages to tinder. Gordon came off the board the second RB and takes his talents to San Diego, which even Ray Charles saw coming. He takes over from new Eagle Ryan Mathews as the two-down runner for the Chargers, alongside passing down back and resident "lunchpail guy" Danny Woodhead. Don't take his presence here as a knock on the guy; I think Gordon runs well and can find success in the Chargers' system. But, and you may notice the theme here, one must take a measured approach to his fantasy potential. First off, Gordon is a former Badger. The RB-friendly system and monstrous offensive line at Wisconsin has buoyed otherwise-average backs for over a decade, with their last successful NFL transplant being Ron Dayne in 2000 (Montee Ball hasn't looked too great thus far, but he's still young, so he gets a mulligan for now). While dazzling when he escapes the defense and hits the second level, Gordon sometimes gave up on dirty runs: NFL.com noted him being stuffed on 20% of his runs. Going from one of the top lines in college ball to the 26th-ranked run-blocking unit in the NFL (last year) casts an ominous pallor over the future this stat portends. On the other hand, his shifty footwork and fluid hips help him to escape tackles, as evidenced by his 1200 yards after contact last year. Plus, San Diego's line improved somewhat after the season, having added Orlando Franklin and TJ Clemmings into the mix. Gordon adds nil to the pass game due to shaky protection and lobster claws, so his opportunities are already limited early on. He'll have to simultaneously run near optimal efficiency (difficult) and rip off some home runs (slightly less difficult) to return on his owner's almost bombastic investment. San Diego draws a somewhat tough RB schedule this year, but gets to play Oakland championship week. I expect Gordon to start slow but close the year as a solid RB2; he should be avoided at his draft-day price, but may prove a juicy trade chip as the year progresses.

--Lucio Leone
@thethirdesquire